I debated whether to post this or not. But then, I realized that hiding the truth even to spare someone is a kind of lie. And letting them believe a lie is not doing them any favors. At the same time, I don't want to damage anyone's faith or reputation unduly, so I am going to stay very anonymous and use pronoun swapping to further shield the person's identity. Chances are he will never read this, but someone who knows her (see how that works) might. If you decide to share it with the person, that's up to you. I ask any reader to be sensitive.
The other day I met someone who walked into this place and very quickly introduced himself to me with a good deal of flourish and formality about who had invited her and why he was there, etc. I don't know why she introduced herself to me, perhaps he thought I was someone important. But being the kind of person I am, I am instantly turned off by any pretense at someone being special because of who they know or what they do. So in an effort to politely express that, I returned the introduction, "Hi, I'm Cav. I'm nobody."
As soon as I said it, his eyes softened and she began to concernedly explain that I truly was somebody in a mealy voice that further turned me off. "Here, we go," I thought. "I should have seen this coming." But I just politely excused myself from the whole thing and went about my business. Soon, though he was back asking me if I was an artist. No? Maybe a musician? No, huh. Finally trying to end this unnecessary bolstering of my self-esteem, I said, "I organize. That's what I do." Which I was actually doing at the moment; trying to set something up for her, which she was too involved in my bolstering to help me with. "I set stuff up for ____." I said indicating what I was doing and inserting his self-proclaimed title in the blank.
"See, there's something!" was the sappy reply.
So chalk it up to different strokes, it takes all kinds, whatever. I went on with my evening. But later as we were about to leave this person finds me again and has to, "give me a Word."
OK, sidebar. If you aren't familiar with the term, "give a Word", it's used in certain sects of Christianity to indicate a special message from God. If you do know the term, please understand that those from other traditions (like me) find it, at best, an excuse to tell us whatever emotional sentiment happened to occur to you at the moment. And opinions on it range down from there through insipid, presumptuous, and even heretical. So if you want to get along with someone from a different sect, hold off on this phrase until you know where they stand. End sidebar.
So, now I'm totally completely uninterested in anything he has to say. But in the interest of polite brotherhood, I opted to simply listen politely rather than start an argument or offend someone who might be legitimately thinking she's doing good.
The "word" was that I was a craftsman and artist, even though I don't thinkso and when I expressed it by dancing as she had seen me do a few minutes before it had "changed the atmosphere." Then he capped it with some vague Bible references that I knew but didn't see the relevance of. But I thanked her and I could tell he was looking for more of a response. So I turned the conversation to other more general topics and ended with as genuine of a 'nice to meet you' as I could manage.
So, you might be thinking, what a jerk I am for discounting this sensitive soul's attempt to help me. But if someone is thinking a duck is a flamingo and publicly declaring it, am I not cruel to leave them uncorrected? Or to be more realistic, if someone is repeatedly calling a new acquaintance by the wrong name, am I not right to point that out, even if it results in momentary embarassment?
So here is what I want to say to this person. Please read it with as much love and tenderness as you can: You were wrong. You weren't hearing anything special from God about me. You misinterpreted just about everything I said. And you were very nearly offensive to my brand of faith. I won't go so far as to say there is never anything true in the way you practice your faith, but in this case, you were totally off.
I know who I am, good and bad. At least as much as any human can, and probably a good deal more than most, as evidenced by this blog. I know where my true value lies. I give God the glory for that. But culturally, I find it offensive and morally wrong to place any human above another. So I wasn't going to brag about myself to a total stranger.
I can't honestly say, I've never dropped a name or asked for a special introduction. But I view these times as failings and ask God to help me become more like the servant Jesus was, who wouldn't even answer the false accusations against him. In fact, like I said, I wouldn't even be saying this if I didn't think it wrong to withhold the truth when I have the power to potentially open someone's eyes.
Secondly, I come from a tradition where what you do is not considered to be from God. We read the same verses and arrive at different conclusions and styles. Neither of us can categorically prove the other wrong. God will reveal the truth to us as we grow. So until that time, I'm willing to respect your beliefs and ways. I ask that you also respect mine.
So reader, if you find this sounding uncannily like you (whether it was you or not) please know I don't hate you. I think you were trying to do good. But please recognize that not everyone understands or even approves of what you do. If you would call those of us brothers, then maybe you should tone it back a little, especially if this is the first time you meet someone.
Imagine how much damage you could do to someone's faith if they believed you were hearing from God but were totally wrong. Does that mean God is wrong? Or are you a liar? Or maybe just a lunatic? I'm not saying this is what I think of you, because I understand what you were attempting. But this is what you might look like to someone who doesn't know better. So don't bruise a reed.
I speak for the trees.
Showing posts with label denominations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label denominations. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 25, 2016
Tuesday, April 9, 2013
41,000
There are an estimated 41,000 Christian denominations. This varies depending on how you count, but lower numbers are around 33,000. Wow. That's a lot. And I'm sure this doesn't pick up many 'flavors' and styles within denominations.
The fact that there are so many doesn't really concern me. Humans are a persnickity people who love to lump and split and join and faction. Especially with things so dear to our hearts, like sports teams, and colleges, and fashion styles, landscaping, music, and religion. I believe this to be a natural, though often perverted and at times over active tendency based in our genetic tribalism. I've said it before; wolves have packs, birds have flocks, humans have tribes. Best to simply accept it and move on.
But anyway, the thing that concerns me is what happens amongst Christians...they tend to assume people are on their side. I can't tell you how many times I've talked to someone who finds out I'm a Christian who then assumes I believe so many things that they associate with it. When statistically, I'm far less likely to believe what they do. Of course it would be more prudent to discover a little more about my beliefs before getting into controversial topics, or simply avoid them altogether, but prudence is not a popular quality, nor is logic taught widely enough to achieve the same effect simply from efficiency.
So why do so many people automatically assume I am of their particular bent in what is truthfully quite a diverse pool? Some of it is probably that people don't really encounter that many of the denominations in their lives. Many are very small and regionalized, so it's a much smaller set of groups people encounter. But even if there were only five major groups (I believe most people encounter far more than that) the beliefs could be different enough to teach us we may not be talking to someone who believes like we do.
So then there's training. Most people really only know one or two in any depth. Even if they've encountered others. And if we know more, we're usually taught they are wrong. This isn't usually the actual teaching, nor the reason the denominations split. As CS Lewis said, those at the center of the wheel are much closer together than those at the end of the spokes. If you research it, you'll find it is usually a very minor point of order or belief that caused the split. Then culture and human nature did the rest.
But to return to the point, people may assume I believe like them, because I wouldn't be where they are, and friendly, if I didn't. Or else, I've just confessed I do (in their mind) by the use of the term Christian, which they take to mean their version of it (which could be the only version they know).
Then some of it may be due to the fact that we don't talk about it in America. I truthfully talked more publicly about my faith, and to a much more receptive audience, I might add, in Japan. Coming from a pluralistic background, and in the safety of their decidedly non-Christian culture, my beliefs were no threat to them. I was in no danger of wrecking their country with my weird ways. So they could be genuinely curious and respectful. I don't know about other countries, but I imagine other cultures range up and down the spectrum of tolerance from my two experiences.
Anyway, we don't talk about religion much in America, so it's almost a cagey thing to even bring up...even in a church. We aren't used to explaining our beliefs or talking openly about them. So when someone finds a 'clue' that I might share their beliefs, they drop guard and assume without thinking about the reality.
To branch out a bit, I'm convinced that many people abandon the term Christian altogether for more or less the same reasons. Some don't want to be associated with the notion they have in their head of one denomination or experience when really their beliefs are very close to many other types of Christianity. Some don't want others to think they're "one of those people" because of the negative connotation they bring to it.
So doesn't one of these denominations have to be right? How can I be so loose about it? Well, sure, Truth, by definition can't be pluralistic. But we're talking about human systems here. At the root of Christianity there are some basic tenets that most groups will align on. For one, they all center on the man Jesus. They may differ on exactly who he was or what he did, but those distinctions are for the individual to root out. We also all pretty much follow the same moral code...which incidentally we share with every other major world religion because (here's a secret), it wasn't created by Jesus. It's innate to all humans. The Bible even talks about this. The rest is mostly just style, culture, and opinion.
Of course, ruling out all the distinctions for a watery ecumenical faith is not good either. I'm simply suggesting we, first of all, know what we believe and recognize it as part of a wondrous diversity. The God who could generate such a world of lifeforms could certainly reflect some diversity in music style and opinion. Secondly, don't be afraid to explain your beliefs...which is tied to my third point: don't assume others believe the same way. Go ahead and investigate and decide what's right for yourself. Then stick to it. But just because I go to certain place or say a certain thing, doesn't mean I'm also number 31,234...I could just as well be 31,235, or even 14,657! And my version may just have an answer for the burning problem you want to talk about.
The fact that there are so many doesn't really concern me. Humans are a persnickity people who love to lump and split and join and faction. Especially with things so dear to our hearts, like sports teams, and colleges, and fashion styles, landscaping, music, and religion. I believe this to be a natural, though often perverted and at times over active tendency based in our genetic tribalism. I've said it before; wolves have packs, birds have flocks, humans have tribes. Best to simply accept it and move on.
But anyway, the thing that concerns me is what happens amongst Christians...they tend to assume people are on their side. I can't tell you how many times I've talked to someone who finds out I'm a Christian who then assumes I believe so many things that they associate with it. When statistically, I'm far less likely to believe what they do. Of course it would be more prudent to discover a little more about my beliefs before getting into controversial topics, or simply avoid them altogether, but prudence is not a popular quality, nor is logic taught widely enough to achieve the same effect simply from efficiency.
So why do so many people automatically assume I am of their particular bent in what is truthfully quite a diverse pool? Some of it is probably that people don't really encounter that many of the denominations in their lives. Many are very small and regionalized, so it's a much smaller set of groups people encounter. But even if there were only five major groups (I believe most people encounter far more than that) the beliefs could be different enough to teach us we may not be talking to someone who believes like we do.
So then there's training. Most people really only know one or two in any depth. Even if they've encountered others. And if we know more, we're usually taught they are wrong. This isn't usually the actual teaching, nor the reason the denominations split. As CS Lewis said, those at the center of the wheel are much closer together than those at the end of the spokes. If you research it, you'll find it is usually a very minor point of order or belief that caused the split. Then culture and human nature did the rest.
But to return to the point, people may assume I believe like them, because I wouldn't be where they are, and friendly, if I didn't. Or else, I've just confessed I do (in their mind) by the use of the term Christian, which they take to mean their version of it (which could be the only version they know).
Then some of it may be due to the fact that we don't talk about it in America. I truthfully talked more publicly about my faith, and to a much more receptive audience, I might add, in Japan. Coming from a pluralistic background, and in the safety of their decidedly non-Christian culture, my beliefs were no threat to them. I was in no danger of wrecking their country with my weird ways. So they could be genuinely curious and respectful. I don't know about other countries, but I imagine other cultures range up and down the spectrum of tolerance from my two experiences.
Anyway, we don't talk about religion much in America, so it's almost a cagey thing to even bring up...even in a church. We aren't used to explaining our beliefs or talking openly about them. So when someone finds a 'clue' that I might share their beliefs, they drop guard and assume without thinking about the reality.
To branch out a bit, I'm convinced that many people abandon the term Christian altogether for more or less the same reasons. Some don't want to be associated with the notion they have in their head of one denomination or experience when really their beliefs are very close to many other types of Christianity. Some don't want others to think they're "one of those people" because of the negative connotation they bring to it.
So doesn't one of these denominations have to be right? How can I be so loose about it? Well, sure, Truth, by definition can't be pluralistic. But we're talking about human systems here. At the root of Christianity there are some basic tenets that most groups will align on. For one, they all center on the man Jesus. They may differ on exactly who he was or what he did, but those distinctions are for the individual to root out. We also all pretty much follow the same moral code...which incidentally we share with every other major world religion because (here's a secret), it wasn't created by Jesus. It's innate to all humans. The Bible even talks about this. The rest is mostly just style, culture, and opinion.
Of course, ruling out all the distinctions for a watery ecumenical faith is not good either. I'm simply suggesting we, first of all, know what we believe and recognize it as part of a wondrous diversity. The God who could generate such a world of lifeforms could certainly reflect some diversity in music style and opinion. Secondly, don't be afraid to explain your beliefs...which is tied to my third point: don't assume others believe the same way. Go ahead and investigate and decide what's right for yourself. Then stick to it. But just because I go to certain place or say a certain thing, doesn't mean I'm also number 31,234...I could just as well be 31,235, or even 14,657! And my version may just have an answer for the burning problem you want to talk about.
Labels:
acceptance,
Christianity,
denominations,
diversity,
faith,
logic,
prudence,
tolerance
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
